👋 Join us for a special webinar Thursday, January 11th
Learn More

Independent Contractors, After-hours Maintenance Calls, Overtime, On-site Managers: Are You Protected?

ethan-lieber-latchel-ceo
Ethan Lieber
July 13, 2018
Independent Contractors, After-hours Maintenance Calls, Overtime, On-site Managers: Are You Protected?

Are you protected when it comes to paying your employees and independent contractors? Recent legal challenges in California drawn from case law in Connecticut may open up the real estate profession to employment questions around independent contractors. In this article, we also review the laws around overtime and on-site managers in California. These decisions may have an impact far beyond California.

What happened in California?

In April earlier this year, the California Supreme Court issued a decision on Dynamex Operations West, Inc. v. Superior Court of Los Angeles. This decision established a few important precedents and could have an impact on the real estate industry.

Here are the key precedents:

  1. It established that all workers in California are presumed to be employees until proven otherwise. This means unless you are certain your workers are independent contractors, you are liable for taxes, benefits, sick time, and more.
  2. It eliminated the previous “Borello test” for determining if a worker was in independent contractor. (note: California’s Department of Industrial Relations’ website is out of date at the time of this writing and still relies on the Borello test in its FAQ–this is why it is so important to consult a lawyer!)
  3. It established a new “ABC test”. What is the ABC Test? The Labor Employment Law Blog summarizes is as follows:

“(A) that the worker is free from the control and direction of the hiring entity in connection with the performance of the work, both under the contract for the performance of the work and in fact;

(B) that the worker performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business; and

(C) that the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business of the same nature as the work performed”

— The Labor & Employment Law Blog

In the case of the Dynamex decision, the California Supreme Court ruled that delivery driver work was indeed inside the usual course of business for a delivery company.

What Does This Mean For Your Business?

Regardless of whether or not you are a California employer, you should protect yourself. The California decision drew from Connecticut case law and could feasibly be used to motivate lawsuits in other states.

The most interesting and potentially litigious aspect of this decision is whether or not the Independent Contractor’s work is supervised or controlled. If you have independent contractors (and most real estate offices have independent contractor agents), this ruling would prohibit you from supervising them as they perform their work. Brokers, however, are required to supervise their agents by law. This can put you in a delicate situation as a broker or business owner.

What can you do to protect yourself with Independent Contractors?

First, consider the ABC test when hiring independent contractors. You should always consult a lawyer when making hiring and contracting decisions. Many aspects of the ABC test apply to jurisdictions beyond California. And with the increase in “gig economy” workers, many other states are tightening their independent contractor definitions. Ignore these changes at your own peril.

Second, have an arbitration agreement in your independent contractor agreement. Templates are readily available online (you should always consult a lawyer). The Supreme Court recently ruled that employers are allowed to have arbitration agreements in their employment contracts (Epic Systems Corp. v. Lewis). This decides the issue for employees, but does not cover independent contractors. The Supreme Court is set to hear arguments for a case regarding arbitration clauses on October 3, 2018 (New Prime Inc. v. Oliveira; note: this applies specifically to the transportation industry). Arbitration agreements with other businesses and consumers are fairly common and have been upheld by the Supreme Court in the past.

What about overtime for property managers?

At Latchel, many of our clients have come to us because they were concerned about overtime and labor laws affecting their property managers. In California, for example, there are complex laws around employment, wages, and overtime for property managers. Running afoul of labor laws can be extremely costly for your business. These liabilities extend well beyond California.

What are the laws around on-site managers in California?

Do your on-site managers take after-hours maintenance calls? Are you compensating your on-site managers appropriately? The laws can be very complex if you employ 26 or more people.

Some key points to keep in mind:

  1. Your on-site managers must be employees. This means they are owed sick time, vacation, tax deductions, benefits, etc.
  2. They must be paid at least minimum wage for time worked (this can range from $10.50 – $15.00/hr+).
  3. You can only deduct $593.05 from wages per month if you employ a single manager ($877.26 if you employ a couple living in the same unit). This means if your local minimum wage is $11/hr, you MUST cut a check to your on-site manager if they work more than 54 hours in a month. That’s less than 13 hours of work per week. (note: you can only deduct up to 2/3rds of the rental value, so if you are employing a couple in an apartment renting for $1300/month, you must deduct less)
  4. If the resident is on-site, the maximum RENT you can charge is $593.05 (or $877.26 if you are employing a couple). There is an exemption for this as long as the wage payments and rent payments are made using separate checks. In other words, you must still pay your on-site managers their wages and then they must submit a separate rent check. The total rent is still limited to 2/3rds of the market rate.
  5. Compensated time does NOT include all “on-call” time (e.g. 24 hours a day for many property managers), only the time actively spent engaged in duties, such as overseeing handyman work or showing units. All of this time must be compensated (see Von Nothdurft v. Steck).
  6. It is the responsibility of the company to track the employee’s time.

What about salaried property managers?

Many employers mistakenly believe that because an employee is salaried they are exempt from overtime laws. This is not true. Exempt vs. non-exempt classifications are what matter.

Currently, property managers who are paid more than $455/week ($23,660/year) do fall under exempt employees, provided that they meet the requirements for administrative employees. The $455/week applies, even if the property manager does not work full time. This means your 30/hr/week part-time property manager needs to be earning at least $15.17/hr.

However, in May 2016, the Department of Labor increased this threshold to $913/week. This was challenged in court and ultimately struck down (see Nevada v. US Department of Labor) because the Texas Federal Court of Appeals found this threshold to be too high. The Department of Labor is currently evaluating the appropriate minimum salary level, which may affect many property manager employees.

It is important to remember that the above only applies to federal laws. State and local laws may be more restrictive. For example in California, exempt employees must be paid at least twice the state minimum wage.

What if none of these apply to me?

Suppose you are protected from all of the above: all of your property managers are employees. All of them are exempt employees being compensated appropriately with high salaries. Why should you care about how much they have to work after hours?

Hult International Business school produced an incredibly well-researched infographic on the costs of sleep deprivation on productivity. Their research suggests the average organization loses $2,280/year per sleep deprived employee in lost productivity.

Sleep deprivation greatly reduces the following cognitive functions:

  1. Understanding and communicating in dynamic, rapidly changing environments (like property management!)
  2. Assessing risk and anticipating consequences (what are property managers if not risk managers?
  3. Coming up with creative solutions to problems (is your organization facing the same problems year after year?)
  4. Multi-tasking and decision making (what property manager is not constantly multi-tasking?)
  5. Emotional intelligence, empathy, and self-awareness (are sleep deprived people pleasant to be around?)

Want to free yourself and your employees to be more productive? Want to reduce the risk your business faces? Schedule a free consultation with one of Latchel’s experts to see if we can help you be more productive, effective, and profitable.

This blog was not written by a lawyer and does not provide legal advice. If you need legal advice, please contact a reputable attorney.

Share this
Related Posts

See why property managers love using Latchel

Unlock the Potential of Digital Insurance
Launch a tailored renter's insurance program

Sure provides tailored renter’s insurance that enables property managers, owners, and residents to protect their property, minimize risk, and experience the peace of mind that comes with the protection of your assets and business.

Most leases require renters insurance. So, we’ve partnered with Sure to provide that option for your residents. While residents aren’t required to use Sure to meet the renter’s insurance requirement, this is still a convenient option you can offer to your tenants. 

All services and products are provided by Sure, not Latchel subject to Sure’s terms and conditions.

Property Inspection Platform
Automate and Organize Inspections with RentCheck
check-mark-icon

Make Inspections Easier
RentCheck saves time by enabling residents to complete inspections on their own. Customization and automation ensure the job gets done.

check-mark-icon

Stop Wasting Time
Schedule inspections for all stages of the lease cycle at any cadence you choose. RentCheck handles the reminders.

check-mark-icon

Instantly Submit Work Orders
Take advantage of Latchel's integration with RentCheck to instantly submit a work order for any maintenance issues that pop up on an inspection.

check-mark-icon

Modernize Your Process
Easily compare new and existing inspection reports, side-by-side, and avoid security deposit disputes.

check-mark-icon

Prompt Routine Filter Changes and Resident Tasks
Schedule resident reminders to replace filters and other upkeep tasks over the course of the lease lifecycle.

To learn more about RentCheck, talk with a Latchel benefits expert today. All services and products are provided by RentCheck, not Latchel, and subject to RentCheck’s terms and conditions.

Affordable Pest Control

Access world class pest control for a fraction of the normal price. No need for new software or a complicated setup.

check-mark-icon

Easy Pest Control
Residents simply reach out to Cover Pest if there is a pest issue, and Cover Pest takes it from there.

check-mark-icon

Clarity on Who Pays the Bill
No more awkward conversations about who is responsible for the bill! With Cover Pest as a resident benefit, residents get pest control for covered pests without an additional cost.

check-mark-icon

Vendor Sourcing
No more sourcing for vendors! Cover Pest will source and coordinate with vendors for each pest control request

To learn more about Cover Pest, talk to a Latchel benefits specialist today.  All services and products are provided by Cover Pest, not Latchel, and subject to Cover Pest’s terms and conditions.

Air Filter Delivery Subscription

FilterTime is an air filter delivery service that makes it easy and convenient for residents to replace their air filters. FilterTime customers can protect their HVAC system, reduce dust and pollen, save money on energy costs, and more by leveraging this delivery service.

check-mark-icon

Reduce Labor for HVAC Issues
Filter delivery service results in a 38% reduction of total HVAC ticket requests.

check-mark-icon

Cost Savings on HVAC Repairs
Average HVAC repair costs have increased by 48.7% year over year. an air filter delivery subscription can cut costs up to $250-300 per property per year.

check-mark-icon

Energy Reduction
Filter delivery is saving residents $14.82 per month in energy costs.

How it works:

Choose from almost every size and type of air filter including custom-made sizes

Choose how often you want your filters delivered

smile-icon

 A box of brand new air filters delivered to your resident’s front door

To learn more about FilterTime, talk with a Latchel benefits specialist today. All services and products are provided by FilterTime, not Latchel subject to FilterTime’s terms and conditions.

Boost resident satisfaction and drive good resident behavior through a rewards, incentives, and credit building program
check-mark-icon

Drive On-Time Rent Payments
Piñata rewards renters for on-time rent payments through Piñata cash, and boosts renter's credit scores for online payments.

check-mark-icon

Boost Resident Satisfaction
$30 gift card to use at select brands and businesses, $25 restaurant card, 720 annual Piñata Cash to use on rewards, Early lease renewal gift.

check-mark-icon

Attract and Retain Renters
2 out of 3 renters prefer properties with rent reporting. Plus, residents get incentives for early lease renewals.

check-mark-icon

Rewards Residents Love
Residents can use Piñata Cash on brands they know and love, such as: Starbucks, Amazon, Sephora, Lego, Target, Walmart, Home Depot, Lowes, Doordash, Best Buy, and many more!

Piñata Cash

Residents easily earn Piñata Cash any day of the month by doing things like taking surveys, referring friends, or trying out new products.

Residents also get access to big-ticket giveaways, limited drops and super surges!

And, with exclusive access to our marketplace with over 300,000 deals, residents can squirrel away up to $4,500 annually.

To learn more about Piñata, talk with a member of our benefits team today. All services and products are provided by Piñata, not Latchel subject to Piñata’s terms and conditions.

Master Liability Insurance

Now you have one less thing to worry about with a Master Liability Policy through Obie.

check-mark-icon

Affordable Coverage
Affordable policies available with liability coverage starting at $100,000 and up to $300,000 to meet any property manager insurance requirements.

check-mark-icon

Stay 100% Compliant
Master policy provides $100,000 for management companies and owners by ensuring 100% of occupied homes and units are covered for property damage liability issues relating to resident negligence.

check-mark-icon

Peace of Mind
Liability coverages include perils such as fire, smoke, water, explosion, overflow of sewer, and many others that provide coverage for damages you (the resident) may cause to your unit or home

check-mark-icon

Personal Liability
Personal liability coverage is automatically include to protect you against claims where you may be considered legally liable. (Bodily injury claims, dog bite claims, and more)

check-mark-icon

Additional Coverages
Additional/expanded coverages are also available. (Pet damage, identity fraud, theft/vandalism, and more are available!)

All services and products are provided through Obie and are subject to Obie’s terms and conditions.

👋 Join us for a special webinar Thursday, January 11th